Editorial Cycle
Certain features of the examination of charred documents: international experience
Abstract
In modern forensic science, particular attention is given to the problem of recovering information from documents damaged by thermal exposure. The destruction of documents by burning is often used as a method of concealing criminal activity, which presents serious challenges for investigations. In this regard, the study of possibilities for restoring such documents acquires significant practical and theoretical importance. The aim of this article is to provide a comprehensive analysis of modern methods and approaches for examining burned documents within the framework of forensic technical expertise, taking into account the international experience of forensic experts in this field. The novelty of the study lies in the systematization and localization of methods from foreign scientific environments, which have not previously been presented in such a format. As a result, more than ten research methods were analyzed, which are effectively used by forensic experts in various countries for documents with different levels of damage. Recommendations are provided for choosing a specific method depending on the degree of charring of the document and the type of ink used. The conclusions emphasize the need for an interdisciplinary approach, the necessity of researching and combining various methods (physical, chemical, digital, etc.), as well as the need to improve methodological guidelines for experts in this field. The implementation of international experience in the Ukrainian practice of forensic technical examination of charred documents will contribute to increasing the effectiveness of information recovery and the quality of expert conclusions. Cooperation with international organizations and the adoption of advanced methodologies enhance the efficiency of examinations and ensure high-quality standards. The application of international practices in the study of charred documents can significantly improve the quality and effectiveness of forensic technical expertise in Ukraine. The use of modern methods and technologies, as well as international cooperation, are key factors for success in this area. The results of this research can be used to modernize the methodologies of forensic analysis of documents damaged by arson, taking into account contemporary scientific achievements and the needs of criminal justice. The proposed approaches will contribute to the unification of expert practice in Ukraine in accordance with international standards.
References
Джерел:
27
References
Джерел: 27-
1
Allen, M. J. (2015). Foundations of forensic document analysis: theory and practice. UK: John Wiley and Sons Ltd, 272.
-
2
André Braz, Maria López-López, Carmen García-Ruiz. (2013). Raman spectroscopy for forensic analysis of inks in questioned documents, Forensic Science International, Volume 232, Issues 1–3. 206-212. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2013.07.017.
-
3
Bartha, A. and Duxbury, N.W. (1968). Restoration and Preservation of Charred Documents. Can Soc Forensic Sci J 1: 1-4.
-
4
Bartha, A. (1973). Restoration and preservation of typewriting and printing on charred documents. Can Soc Forensic Sci J 6. 111-112.
-
5
Carolina S. Silva, Maria Fernanda Pimentel, Ricardo S. Honorato, Celio Pasquini, José M. Prats-Montalbáne, Alberto Ferrer (2014). Near Infrared Hyperspectral Imaging for forensic analysis of document forgery. July. The Analyst. 139 (20) DOI:10.1039/C4AN00961D.
-
6
Chayal, V. M., Paite, N. L., Barik, A. K., Kumar, S., Bhattacharya, S., & Amin, H. Stabilization and Examination of Charred Documents: A Systematic Review. DOI:10.37421/2157-7145.2023.14.531
-
7
Chetna Rajendra Tidke, K.P.S Kushwaha (2019). Decipherment of Ball Point Pen Writings on the Charred/ Burnt Paper. International Journal of Forensic Science; 2(1):21-24.
-
8
Cicconi F., Lazic V., Palucci A., Almeida Assis A.C., Saverio Romolo F. (2020). Forensic Analysis of Commercial Inks by Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS). Sensors (Basel). Jul 4; 20(13):3744. DOI: 10.3390/s20133744.PMID: 32635434; PMCID: PMC7374342.
-
9
de Haan J.D. and Icove D. J. (2014). Kirk’s Fire Investigation (7 uppl.). Essex: Pearson Education Ltd.
-
10
Doud, Donald, and Ordway, Hilton (1955). Document Examiner Aids the Arson Investigation, The. J Crim L Criminology Police Sci. 46. 404.
-
11
Ethier, Andrew, and Pardeep Jasra. (2016). Detection of Writing and Fingerprints on Burnt Documents Using the Video Spectral Comparator. J Emerg Forensic Sci Res. 1. 18-26.
-
12
Horswell, John (2004). Crime scene investigation. The Practice of Crime Scene Investigation. United States: CRC Press.
-
13
Kristiane de Cássia Mariotti, Rafael Scorsatto Ortiz, Marco Flôres Ferrão (2023). Hyperspectral imaging in forensic science: An overview of major application areas. Sci Justice. May ;63(3). 387-395. DOI: 10.1016/j.scijus.2023.04.003.Epub 2023 Apr 7.
-
14
Kumar, M., and Kaur, R. (2018). A Review-Burnt or Charred Documents. Int J Inform Computing Sci. 5. 1-9.
-
15
Martynenko, N. (2025). Methodological support for forensic science in the USA and Ukraine: A comparative study. Forensic Sci Int Synerg. Jan 4;10:100571. DOI: 10.1016/j.fsisyn.2024.100571. PMID: 39867259; PMCID: PMC11757784.
-
16
Mirza, Yasar, Lav, Kesharwani (2017). Comparative study for recovery of written contents on different burnt papers. Int J Currt Res. 9. 56929-56931.
-
17
Olson, Larry A. (2020). Examination of Cut, torn, Shredded, and Perforated Documents. Forensic Document Examination in the 21st Century. USA: CRC Press,
-
18
R. Brent Ostrum (2006). Application of Hyperspectral Imaging to Forensic Document Examination Problems. Journal of the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners, Volume 9, Issue 2. 85-93. DOI: 10.69525/jasqde.134.
-
19
Shipra, Rohatgi, Gupta Shruti and Sharma Madhulika. (2017). A Study to Focus on Augmentation of Preexisting Methodologies for Tampered Document Examination. Res J Pharm Technol. 10. 4085-4089.
-
20
Sharma, Bhoopesh Kumar. (2020). Decipherment of the Written and Printed Matter on the Charred Document Using UV and IR under Different Wavelengths // International Conference on Computation, Automation and Knowledge Management (ICCAKM), Dubai, United Arab Emirates: IEEE publisher.
-
21
Shiv, Kunal. (2020). Decipherment of the Written Contents in Different Types of Damaged Documents with Optical Imaging Techniques. J Seybold Rep. 15. 9211.
-
22
Tholl, Joseph. (1948). Infrared in Court: Uses of Photographs in Civil and Criminal Cases. Am Bar Assoc. J 54. 776-851.
-
23
Forensic Science and Law, USA: CRC Press, (2005).
-
24
Tonazzini, Anna. (2019). Analytical and mathematical methods for revealing hidden details in ancient manuscripts and paintings. A review. J Adv Res 17. 31-42.
-
25
Vastrick, Thomas W. (2005). Questioned Document Examination. Forensic Science and Law, USA: CRC Press.
-
26
Vorobej, O. V., Mel’nikov, І. M., Voloshin, O. G. (2008). Tehnіko-krimіnalіstichne doslіdzhennja dokumentіv. Navchal’no-metodichnij posіbnik. Kiїv. 206-209. [in Ukrainian].