Certain Aspects of Understanding Criminal Offense Subject Matter Under Article 191 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to highlight certain aspects of the subject matter of criminal offense in crimes involving misappropriation, embezzlement of property or its conversion by malversation. The methodological framework of the study has been developed taking into account general scientific and special methods of scientific inquiry. A number of scientific methods have been applied, including dogmatic, hermeneutic, comparative, extrapolation and analogy. The author proves that the subject matter of misappropriation or embezzlement of somebody else’s property, set out in Parts. 1 and 2 of Article 191 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, is property entrusted to a person or under his/her administration—that is, property over which the person has special authority. Entrusted is property that is transferred to a person for possession or use in accordance with a transaction or in connection with the performance of duties associated with the position held. Evidence that property is entrusted to a person is that this person actually possesses the property and this property is under his/her control. It has been established that property under a person’s administration should be understood as property that is not under the physical control of a person, but transferred to him/her by the owner or his/her authorized representative on the terms of granting this person a certain amount of rights to own, use and dispose of this property, which ensures the possibility of operational management of it to achieve a certain goal, determined by the owner or without such, that is, the person is granted a certain authority to manage and dispose of property. The criterion for distinguishing between entrusted property and property under a person’s administration is the nature of a legal relationship between the owner and the person: for entrusted property, this is a relationship with the actual possibility of ownership, that is, the person actually possesses property; for property under a person’s administration, this is a relationship with the presence of a certain amount of ownership rights over the property, in other words, the person may not physically possess it. It is emphasized that the definition of the subject of the criminal offense under Art. 191 of the CCU is inextricably linked to the establishment of crime subject status. It is noted that an official is a person who has authority under the position held and performs a range of functions consistent with that position, including: administrative and economic functions; organizational and executive functions; and functions as a representative of the government or local self-government.
Keywords:
appropriation
embezzlement
conversion of property
subject matter of offense
somebody else’s property
entrusted property
property under administration
abuse
official
official standing
References
Джерел:
53
References
Джерел: 53-
1
Antoniuk, N. O. (2012). Kryminalno-pravova okhorona vlasnosti [Criminal Law Protection of Property]: navch. posibnyk. Lviv : LNU imeni Ivana Franka. 514 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
3
Demydova, L. M. (2010). Maino yak predmet zlochynu [Property as the subject of a crime]. Visnyk Akademii pravovykh nauk Ukrainy. Vyp. 3. S. 267–275. [in Ukrainian].
-
5
Dorosh, L. V. (2008). Shchodo efektyvnosti zastosuvannia zakonodavstva pro kryminalnu vidpovidalnist za pryvlasnennia, roztratu maina abo zavolodinni nym shliakhom zlovzhyvannia sluzhbovym stanovyshchem [On the effectiveness of the application of legislation on criminal liability for embezzlement, misappropriation or acquisition of property through abuse of office]. Pytannia borotby zi zlochynnistiu. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats. Vyp. 16. S. 27-35. [in Ukrainian].
-
7
Doroshenko, K. (2024). Pravo na maino yak predmet kryminalnoho pravoporushennia, peredbachenoho statteiu 191 Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy [Property rights as the subject of a criminal offense under Article 191 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine]. Hazeta «Iurydychna praktyka» vid 20.11.2024. URL: https://pravo.ua/pravo-na-maino-iak-predmet-kryminalnoho-pravoporushennia-peredbachenoho-statteiu-191-kryminalnoho-kodeksu-ukrainy/. [in Ukrainian].
-
9
Kharchenko, V. B. (2017). Maino yak predmet zlochyniv proty vlasnosti ta predmet suspilnykh vidnosyn prava vlasnosti na rechi ta inshi rechovi prava [Property as the subject of property crimes and the subject of social relations concerning property rights and other rights in rem]. Visnyk Kryminolohichnoi asotsiatsii Ukrainy. №2 (16). S. 121–131. [in Ukrainian].
-
11
Knyzhenko, O. (2017). Problemy kvalifikatsii pryvlasnennia chy roztraty chuzhoho maina osoboiu, yakii tse maino bulo vvireno, chy perebuvalo v yii vidanni [Issues regarding the classification of the misappropriation or embezzlement of another persons property by an individual to whom such property was entrusted or was under their control]. Naukovyi chasopys Natsionalnoi akademii prokuratury Ukrainy. № 3. S. 82-89. [in Ukrainian].
-
13
Koruptsiini skhemy: yikh kryminalno-pravova kvalifikatsiia i dosudove rozsliduvannia (2019). [Corruption Schemes: Their Criminal Classification and Pre-Trial Investigation] / Za red. M. I. Khavroniuka. Kyiv. 464 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
15
Kryminalne pravo (Osoblyva chastyna). T. 1 (2012). [Criminal Law (Special Part). Vol. 1]: pidruchnyk /za red. O. O. Dudorova, Ye. O. Pysmenskoho. Luhansk : Elton-2. 780 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
17
Kryminalne pravo Ukrainy: Osoblyva chastyna (2015). [Criminal Law of Ukraine: Special Part]: pidruchnyk / za red. V. Ya. Tatsiia, V. I. Borysova, V. I. Tiutiuhina. 5-te vyd., pererob. i dopov. Kharkiv : Pravo. 680 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
19
Kryminalne pravo Ukrainy: Osoblyva chastyna (2020). [Criminal Law of Ukraine: Special Part]: pidruchnyk / za red. V. Ya. Tatsiia, V. I. Borysova, V. I. Tiutiuhina. 6-te vyd. pererob i dopov. Kharkiv. 768 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
21
Kryminalnyi kodeks Ukrainy. Naukovo-praktychnyi komentar. T. 2: Osoblyva chastyna (2013). [The Criminal Code of Ukraine: A Scientific and Practical Commentary. Vol. 2: Special Part] / Iu. V. Baulin, V. I. Borysov, V. I. Tiutiuhin ta in. 5-te vyd., dopov. Kharkiv : Pravo. 1040 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
23
Naukovo-praktychnyi komentar do Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy: U 2 t. T. 1 (2009). [Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine: In 2 vols. Vol. 1] / Za zah. red. P. P. Andrushka, V. H. Honcharenka, Ye. V. Fesenka. 3-tie vyd., pererob. ta dop. Kyiv : Alerta; KNT; Tsentr uchbovoi literatury. 964 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
25
Naukovo-praktychnyi komentar Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy (2016). [A Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine] / za zah. red. O. M. Dzhuzhi, A. V. Savchenka, V. V. Chernieia. Kyiv. 1064 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
27
Naukovo-praktychnyi komentar Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy. 10-te vyd., pererobl ta dopov. (2018). [Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine. 10th ed., revised and expanded] / Za red. M. I. Melnyka, M. I. Khavroniuka. Kyiv. 1360 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
29
Naukovo-praktychnyi komentar Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy: Zlochyny proty vlasnosti (2017). [Scientific and Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine: Crimes Against Property] / Za red. M. I. Khavroniuka. Kyiv : VD «Dakor», 2017. 522 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
31
Oleksiienko, V. A. Osoblyvosti kryminalno-pravovoi kharakterystyky zlochynu, peredbachenoho st. 191 Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy [Features of the criminal law characterization of the offense under Article 191 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine]. URL: https://surl.li/dmbffj [in Ukrainian].
-
33
Oliinyk P. V. Predmet zlochyniv proty vlasnosti: poniattia, vydy, kryminalno-pravove znachennia (2011). [The Subject Matter of Property Crimes: Concept, Types, and Criminal Law Significance] : monohrafiia. Kharkiv : Pravo. 208 s. [in Ukrainian].
-
35
Oliinyk, P. V. (2014). Shchodo vyznachennia poniattia «pravo na maino» yak predmeta zlochyniv proty vlasnosti [On the Definition of the Concept of “Property Rights” as the Object of Property Crimes]. Problemy zakonnosti: zb. nauk. pr. Vyp. 126. S. 146-147. [in Ukrainian].
-
37
Oliinyk, P. V. (2015). Shchodo poniattia predmeta zlochyniv proty vlasnosti [On the Definition of the Concept of “Property Rights” as the Object of Property Crimes]. Problemy zakonnosti: zb. nauk. pr. Vyp. 128. S. 32-33. [in Ukrainian].
-
39
Postanova kolehii suddiv Druhoi sudovoi palaty Kasatsiinoho kryminalnoho sudu Verkhovnoho Sudu u spravi [Ruling of the Panel of Judges of the Second Judicial Chamber of the Cassation Criminal Court of the Supreme Court in the case] № 456/1181/15-k vid 28 liutoho 2019 roku. Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen. URL: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/80181431 [in Ukrainian].
-
41
Pro sudovu praktyku u spravakh pro zlochyny proty vlasnosti (2009). [On Judicial Precedents in Cases Involving Crimes Against Property]. Postanova Plenumu Verkhovnoho Sudu Ukrainy № 10 vid 6 lystopada 2009 roku. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v0010700-09#top. [in Ukrainian].
-
43
Slabchenko, O. A. (2012). Kharakterystyka subiekta zlochynu, peredbachenoho st. 191 KK Ukrainy [Characteristics of the perpetrator of the crime provided for in Article 191 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine]. Pivdennoukrainskyi pravnychyi chasopys. № 3. S. 272-275. [in Ukrainian].
-
45
Smahliuk, O. V. Do pytannia pro vidmezhuvannia shakhraistva vid pryvlasnennia, roztraty maina ao zavolodinnia nym shliakhom zlovzhyvannia sluzhbovym stanovyshchem [On the distinction between fraud and embezzlement, misappropriation of property, or acquisition of property through abuse of official position]. URL: https://lnk.ua/qr/2wn3nYrmC [in Ukrainian].
-
47
Tsyvilnyi kodeks Ukrainy (2003). [Civil Code of Ukraine]: Zakon Ukrainy vid 16.01.2003 № 435-IV (zi zminamy ta dopovnenniamy). Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy (VVR), №№ 40-44. St. 356. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/435-15#Text. [in Ukrainian].
-
49
Tsyvinskyi, O. I. (2022). Osnovni problemy vyznachennia predmeta pryvlasnennia, roztraty maina abo zavolodinnia nym shliakhom zlovzhyvannia sluzhbovym stanovyshchem [Key Issues in Determining the Subject Matter of Embezzlement, Misappropriation, or Misuse of Property Through Abuse of Official Position]. Pravo i suspilstvo. № 5. S. 229-236. DOI https://doi.org/10.32842/2078-3736/2022.5.34 [in Ukrainian].
-
51
Yarmysh, N. M. (2014). Vyznachennia subiekta pryvlasnennia chy rozkradannia chuzhoho maina [Identification of the perpetrator of misappropriation or theft of another persons property]. Visnyk Natsionalnoi akademii prokuratury Ukrainy. № 4 (37). S. 69-76. [in Ukrainian].
-
53
Yarmysh, N. M. (2015). Problemy zastosuvannia statti 191 Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy «Pryvlasnennia, roztrata maina abo zavolodinnia nym shliakhom zlovzhyvannia sluzhbovym stanovyshchem» [Issues Regarding the Application of Article 191 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine: “Misappropriation, Embezzlement, or Acquisition of Property Through Abuse of Official Position”]. Protydiia zlochynnosti: teoriia ta praktyka: zbirnyk materialiv VI Mizhvuzivskoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii studentiv (kursantiv), aspirantiv ta molodykh vchenykh. S. 32-35. [in Ukrainian].
This article is published under the terms of the
Creative
Commons 4.0. Attribution International license.
Full Text
5
1
How to Cite
[1]
Bogomolov O. Certain Aspects of Understanding Criminal Offense Subject Matter Under Article 191 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Archives of Criminology and Forensic Sciences. 2026. Т. 13, № 1. С. 49–59. DOI: https://doi.org/10.32353/acfs.13.2026.02.
Copied!